The Role of the Business Model and Strategy for Business

People will always stress that having a well researched business plan is key before you start your business. Although creating a business plan is often an important step in the evolution of a business, particularly if you need financing or you are not experienced at running a business, it is not necessarily the essential first step. There are two key elements that should be completed prior to the business plan:

  • The business model

  • The strategy

What is a Business Model?

While the word model often stirs up images of mathematical formulas, a business model is in fact a story of how a business works. In general terms, a business model is the method of doing business by which a company can generate revenue. Both start-up ventures and established companies take new products and services to the market through a venture shaped by a specific business model. In their paper, The Role of the Business Model in Capturing Value from Innovation, Henry Chesbrough and Richard S. Rosenbloom outlined the six basic elements of a business model:

  • Articulate the value proposition ? the value created to users by using the product

  • Identify the market segment ? to whom and for what purpose is the product useful; specify how revenue is generated by the firm.

  • Define the value chain ? the sequence of activities and information required to allow a company to design, produce, market, deliver and support its product or service.

  • Estimate the cost structure and profit potential ? using the value chain and value proposition identified.

  • Describe the position of the firm with the value network ? link suppliers, customers, complementors and competitors.

  • Formulate the competitive strategy ? how will you gain and hold your competitive advantage over competitors or potential new entrants.

    Joan Magretta in her article Why Business Models Matter took the concept of the business model a little further. Magretta suggests every business model needs to pass two critical tests, the narrative test and the numbers test. The narrative test must tell a good story and explain how the business works, who is the customer, what do they value and how a company can deliver value to the customer. The numbers test means your profit and loss assumptions must add up. At the most basic level, if your model doesn't work, then your model has failed one of the two tests.

    To begin the modeling process you need to articulate a value proposition on the product or service being provided. The model must then describe the target market. The customer will then value the product on its ability to reduce costs, solve a problem or create new solutions. A market focus is needed to identify what product attributes need to be targeted and how to resolve product trade-offs such as quality versus cost. You also need to identify how much to charge and how the customer will pay.

    Think of business modeling as the managerial equivalent of the scientific method - you start with a hypothesis, which you then test in action and revise when necessary. The business model also plays a part of a planning tool by focusing managements on how all the elements and activities of the business work together as a whole. At the end of the day, the business model should be condensed onto one page consisting of: a diagram outlining how the business generates revenue, how cash flows through the business and how the product flows through the business and; a narrative describing the product/ service components, financial projections or other important elements not captured in the diagram.

    Business Models and Strategy

    It is important to note that completing a business model does not constitute strategic planning. Strategic planning factors in the one thing a business model doesn't; competition.

    What is strategy?

    According to the Collins English Dictionary, strategy is "a particular long-term plan for success". For our purposes, we will consider the essence of strategy as a formula for coping with the competition. Competitive strategy is about being different and the goal for a corporate strategy is to find a position in the industry where the company is unique and can defend itself against market forces. To do this the company must choose a set of activities that can deliver a unique mix of value.

    Market Forces and Strategy

    The determination of a strategy is rooted in determining how a company stacks up against basic market forces, how it can defend itself against these forces and how it can influence these forces. Fortunately, Michael E. Porter in his article How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy defined these market forces for us. Known as Porter's 5 forces they consist of:

  • The industry ? this is the jockeying for position among current competitors, this can consists of price competition, new product introduction or advertising slugfests.

  • The threat of new entrants - the seriousness of the threat of entry depends on the barriers to entry and reaction from existing companies. There are 6 major barriers to entry: 1) economies of scale 2) product differentiation 3) capital requirements 4) cost disadvantages independent of size 5) access to distribution channels 6) government policy. A new company will generally have second thoughts about entering an industry if the incumbent has substantial resources to fight back, the incumbent seems likely to cut prices or industry growth is slow.

  • The threat of substitute products/services - substitutes can place a ceiling on prices that are charged and limit the potential of an industry.

  • The bargaining power of suppliers - suppliers can squeeze profitability by increasing prices or lowering the quality of the goods.

  • The bargaining power of buyers (customers) - customers can force down prices, demand better quality, more service or play competitors off on each other.

    Once you assess how the market forces are affecting competition in your industry and their underlying causes, you can identify the underlying strength and weaknesses of your company, determine where it stands against each force and then determine a plan of action. Plans of action may include:

    • Positioning the company ? match your strengths and weaknesses to the company's industry, build defenses against competitive forces or find a position in the industry where forces are the weakest. You need to know your company's capabilities and the causes of the competitive forces

    • Influencing the balance ? take the offensive, for example innovative marketing can raise brand identification or differentiate the product.

    • Exploiting industry change ? an evolution of an industry can bring changes in competition. For example, in an industry life-cycle growth rates change and/or product differentiation declines; anticipate shifts in the factors underlying these forces and respond to them.

    The framework for analyzing the industry and developing a strategy provides the road map for answering the question "what is the potential of this business?"

    Reconciling the Business Model and Strategy

    I will use a short example to illustrate the difference between a business model and strategy. Although you may think that Wal-Mart pioneered a new business model on its road to success, the reality is that the model was really no different than the one Kmart was using at the time. But it was what Sam Walton chose to do differently than Kmart, such as focusing on small towns as opposed to large cities and everyday low prices, that was the real reason for his success. Although Sam Walton's model was the same as Kmart's, his unique strategy made him a success.

    About The Author

    Jeff Schein is a CGA and offers advisory services in the areas of business planning, business modeling, strategic planning, business analysis and financial management for new ventures and growing small businesses. Visit www.companyworkshop.com or www.companyworkshop.com.

    Oswego taxi to Midway ..
    In The News:

    Hackers and scammers keep looking for ways to break into your Facebook account. Kurt “CyberGuy" Knutsson has some tips to make sure your account is secure.
    Kurt “CyberGuy" Knutsson shows you how to create group texts to reach multiple people at once — and also how to leave them if you get annoyed at the volume of interruptions.
    Tax fraud is on the rise, and hackers are now using identity hijacking and artificial intelligence for tax returns in someone else's name to get a refund.
    Toyota's Punyo soft robot mimics human behavior, using its chest, hips and arms — in addition to its hands — like a human to handle objects,
    Hackers used third-party information to break into Roku accounts, according to the streaming company. Roku says it has secured affected accounts.
    Stay up to date on the latest AI technology advancements and learn about the challenges and opportunities AI presents now and for the future.
    Kurt "CyberGuy" Knutsson explains the simple steps for setting a Wi-Fi hot spot on an Android. If you have internet on your phone, it's easy.
    Dubai recently hosted the first jet suit race with a backdrop of skyscrapers, and one observer says it was straight out of a comic book.
    Kim Komando introduces ways to keep you and your devices safe while traveling. The clever hacks mentioned can protect you from hackers and jackers.
    TikTok CEO Shou Chew published a video Wednesday urging users to "protect your constitutional rights" against a bipartisan bill that would force China to divest from the app.
    Tech guru Kurt "CyberGuy" Knutsson says you can never be too careful with tech passwords. He explains how to keep your information safe.
    The Lighthouse in New Zealand rotates 360 degrees, constantly giving those inside different views around the clock. Built in the 1990s, it's up for sale.
    High school students in Colorado are learning how to design their own AI model projects, including cameras for self-driving cars and apps that can teach other languages.
    Stay up to date on the latest AI technology advancements and learn about the challenges and opportunities AI presents now and for the future.
    Vehicles collect sensitive personal information, which is used to set auto insurance rates. That's partly why auto insurance premiums are rising.
    Honda's Uni-One is a hands-free electric mobility device that can reach speeds of 3.7 mph and support a user weighing up to 242 pounds.
    Kim Komando puts three AI chatbots head-to-head to decide which is the best assistant for modern problems. Compare Google Gemini, ChatGPT, and Perplexity.
    To safeguard personal information on iPhones, users can employ built-in security measures and iCloud Keychain for enhanced privacy. Kurt “CyberGuy" Knutsson shows you how.
    Kurt “CyberGuy" Knutsson introduces you to the City Transformer’s CT-2 electric car, which can seamlessly transition from 8 feet wide on the road to a compact 3 feet for parking.
    Hackers are always looking for new ways to trick targets into downloading malware. Now, they're after cryptocurrency folks via Calendly. Kurt “CyberGuy" Knutsson has the details.
    Kurt “CyberGuy" Knutsson reveals how the Microlino Lite, a compact and eco-friendly vehicle, tackles city traffic congestion with its chic design and small dimensions.
    A new funeral scam targets surviving family members of those who recently died. Scammers reach out to the survivors and pose as funeral home officials.
    Merlin Labs' autonomous pilot could soon hit the commercial airways and may help alleviate a looming pilot shortage, according to CEO Matt George.
    There's a simple way to check your subscriptions on an Android and cancel them. Tech guru Kurt "CyberGuy" Knutsson explains how it is done.
    Hackers use pirated software to target macOS, Android and Windows devices in search of stealing cryptocurrency, according to Kurt "CyberGuy" Knutsson.
  • Effectively Completing the Operations Plan Section of Your Business Plan

    The Operations Plan is a critical component of any business... Read More

    Franchise Companies Come and Go

    Each day we hear of companies entering the franchising industry.... Read More

    Start a Resume Writing Service for Profit

    The resume writing service serves an important role in the... Read More

    Your Small Business Suggestion Box

    A suggestion box is a really good idea for your... Read More

    Family Business and Conflicts

    What is a Family Business? A family business is basically... Read More

    How to Find A Group that Needs Speakers

    How do you find groups that are in need of... Read More

    Serious About Writing A Business Plan... Start A Business Plan Library

    Tap these treasures of ideas. The best money you can... Read More

    Private Investigator Tactics

    A Private Investigator is a professional trained in the art... Read More

    There Is Security in Change... But Use Caution

    It has been said that the only constant is change.... Read More

    SBAs 8(a) Program Can Help Some Companies Compete

    Q: A friend told me that as a woman of... Read More

    Canon City, Colorado - Good for Small Business

    Canon City, Colorado is known for it's 6 Prisons; State... Read More

    Street Wars Between Mobile Car Washers and Mobile Auto Detailers

    There is much competition in the mobile auto detailing business.... Read More

    When and Why YOU Are the Best Writer for Your Business Plan

    WHEN you are operating or planning a small business that... Read More

    Business Relationships Defined

    What makes a business relationship?What really makes a business relationship?... Read More

    The Responsibility Conundrum - Where art Thou?

    Mr/Ms, 'not me' is often on holidays in your business.... Read More

    Small Business Marketing Secrets: Look Like Sizzle, Be The Steak

    You've heard marketing and advertising gurus quip, "Sell the sizzle,... Read More

    Wichita KS; Anything is Possible in Wichita Business

    Just when the entire state was kissing Wichita goodbye, economically... Read More

    Finding the Right People for your Business

    Where do you find the right people for a business... Read More

    Tell Me The Reasons Why I Should Believe You?

    Have you ever heard the phrase, 'PREPONDERANCE OF PROOF'?I recently... Read More

    Leverage The Power of Publicity For Your Small Business

    Your business is only as good as the number of... Read More

    Increase Your Profits with a Point of Sale (POS) System

    Whether you operate a chain of restaurants, a mom-and-pop convenience... Read More

    Where to Find a Cash Windfall of $10,000 to $1,000,000 -- You Never Knew You Had

    There is a rather famous true story called "Acres of... Read More

    Environmental Pressure Washing in Pennsylvania

    If you run a mobile car wash, mobile fleet washing... Read More

    How to Curb Antique Shop Theft Inexpensively

    If you have ever had your antique shop or mall... Read More

    FTC Report on Franchise Rule Making; What Purpose?

    The Federal Trade Commission out of the blue decide in... Read More

    shuttle from Midway Morris ..