Leading the Witness: How Asking Questions as a Trainer Can Limit Learning and Reduce Trust

"Asking questions can be a means of establishing authority, fulfilling leadership functions, and ensuring effective learning. In fact, asking questions is probably the most subtle power you have for controlling people. The person who asks questions always controls the conversation... if we could discipline our minds to ask questions instead, we could lead any conversation to wherever we wanted it because the other person would still be wrapped up in thinking what he or she wanted to say next...One of the rights you have as a trainer is to ask questions and expect answers. This is why question-asking is such a powerful tool. It challenges and avoids confrontation at the same time."

Mitchell, Garry, The Trainer's Handbook: The AMA Guide to Effective Training, Amacom, 1998, p 63.

If you deliver training, odds are you reduce participants' learning and enthusiasm through manipulative questions - like the ones Garry is advocating for -and that you're unaware that you're doing this. I label Garry's approach to questions as manipulative because they require that the trainer ask questions for the purposes of guiding a conversation in a particular direction without disclosing that direction in advance and giving participants a choice about whether they want to go there.

My colleague Sue McKinney and I explored this subject in detail in "The Facilitative Trainer" chapter of The Skilled Facilitator Fieldbook. Today I hope I can help you identify how, if at all, this is happening for you, and offer a way of using questions that avoids the negative consequences above.

When I began my work as a trainer, I often resorted to subtly manipulative questions to achieve my goals in a training session. For example, I'd ask questions I already felt I knew the answer to in hopes that participants would get the "right" "Ahas". Trouble was, this was significantly limiting learning for everyone in ways I couldn't see.

Chris Argyris' research and our client work lead me to believe that this kind of questioning gets people defensive; they don't know why you're asking the questions, they guess, and their guesses often contain negative judgments about you or the training design. All this reduces your credibility and their learning.

I used the following four methods to dramatically reduce this kind of manipulation and increase my effectiveness as a trainer; I continue to use them with colleagues to improve our training work.

~ Identify whether and how you use questions manipulatively. Record and revisit your own training work and/or ask to be observed as you train. Assess where you were being transparent about your reasoning for asking your questions - and where you weren't.

~ Alone and with others, explore what beliefs led you to do this. For example, do your questions indicate you believe that the learners won't "get it" without your "guidance"? Do your questions indicate that there's only one "it" to get, and you know it in advance? These assumptions and beliefs won't be "nice" or "pretty", but until you discover them, you'll continue to act as if they were true, and get consequences you and your participants don't want.

~ Be transparent about the change you're trying to make. If you decide you want to change your approach, let clients, participants and colleagues know, and ask for their feedback- especially during the training.

This last step has turned out to be simply essential for us. When I've tried to avoid doing this, change has either taken much longer or didn't happen at all.

What are your reactions to my thoughts here? I invite you to email me with your thoughts.

? 2005 Matt Beane

Matt Beane is an associate with Roger Schwarz & Associates and co-authored a chapter of the recently published "Skilled Facilitator Fieldbook: Tips, Tools, and Tested Methods for Consultants, Facilitators, Managers, Trainers, and Coaches," available on Amazon.com and via other quality booksellers.

This article was originally published in Fundamental Change, Roger Schwarz & Associates' free, monthly ezine. You can subscribe at: http://www.schwarzassociates.com/fundamental_change.html

In exchange for subscribing, you'll receive a link to a free .pdf copy of "Holding Risky Conversations," a chapter from our recently-published fieldbook.

We write Fundamental Change to help you create workplaces and communities that are simultaneously highly effective and that improve the quality of life.

Every month we:

* Address issues important to you as practitioners and leaders * Share client examples and case studies * Offer tips and tools for challenging situations * Offer resources to help you become more effective.

reliable maid service Deerfield ...
In The News:

Uber Parking launches in 15 U.S. cities after the SpotHero deal, offering upfront prices, Uber One credits, and a future role for robotaxis in garages.
The Fox News AI Newsletter covers the latest artificial intelligence technology advancements, including the challenges and opportunities AI presents now and for the future.
Microsoft Outlook flaw CVE-2026-124194 lets a malicious .msg file expose NTLMv2 authentication data, and Microsoft confirms hackers already exploited it.
Former Secret Service cyberfraud investigator Jason Brown warns AI voice cloning scams could trick families into losing thousands of dollars this holiday season.
A single data broker opt-out may not be enough. Spokeo, Whitepages and BeenVerified can still expose your address and family details to scammers.
Apple Photos now embeds an invisible SynthID watermark in images edited with Apple Intelligence tools like Clean Up, Extend and Reframe in iOS 27.2.
Fortra researchers say fake vacation rental sites use live customer support chats to trick travelers into handing over credit card details this holiday.
Ecolab CEO Christophe Beck says AI data centers could drink as much water as Americans by 2030 unless direct chip cooling and water recycling catch on.
Ring's Drone Cam flies room to room with AI navigation, 2K video and a $249.99 price, but it still awaits FCC authorization before it can ship in the U.S.
Virginia's GPS speed limiter program is already active for reckless driving offenders, but early users report glitches that apply wrong speed limits.
VPN split tunneling lets your banking app skip the encrypted tunnel while other apps stay protected, and the Allow LAN setting can fix printer issues.
A fake E-ZPass email cites a real federal regulation to demand toll payments, but the law it references has nothing to do with collecting tolls.
A credit freeze, fraud alert and identity monitoring each protect different parts of your financial life after a data breach. Here's how to choose.
OpenAI's new classifier flags 48% fewer images for review while detecting similar levels of CSAM, and ChatGPT now suspends users for 24 hours.
USF researchers built an AI mosquito trap with over 98% accuracy as Florida battles its largest dengue outbreak in decades with 524 local cases.
Fake OpenAI event pages promise free ChatGPT Pro subscriptions, then trick employees into handing over Microsoft and Google account credentials.
Ford's new privacy promise pledges not to sell driving data to insurers or brokers, but disabling connected car data sharing could cost you key features.
Google says Videostrong deliberately installed backdoor malware in over 1.3 million Android TV boxes, turning them into a botnet for criminals.
Foundation Future Robotics co-founder Mike LeBlanc says the MK 2 humanoid is ready to engage enemies with machine guns in Ukraine's combat zone.
EAIGLE says its AI camera technology cuts truck check-ins from 10 minutes to under 30 seconds, potentially reducing fuel waste across supply chains.
The Fox News AI Newsletter covers the latest artificial intelligence technology advancements, including the challenges and opportunities AI presents.
After the military, some veterans are left wondering what's next? Nonprofit organization Vets to Drones is helping them take on a new path by becoming certified drone pilots.
Natasha Lopez says a Flock camera system helped a Georgia deputy track her family, and after she spoke out, a fake Facebook page targeted her children.
Data broker opt-outs may not keep your personal information private for long. Five common myths leave retirees especially vulnerable to scams.
What's Nvidia's future after the resignation of CEO Jensen Huang amid scandals? Weigh in here!

The 3 Secrets of Team Motivation

Are workers telling the truth when they say they are... Read More

Story Telling With a Purpose

For a brief time, I tried to sell life insurance.... Read More

Checklist for High Performing Teams

Why do some teams perform well while others struggle? How... Read More

Empower Your Trainees

One of the most memorable quotes that I heard from... Read More

Recruiting Government Workers As Franchisees

Many believe a leaner government promotes better freedoms with respect... Read More

Your Administration Team - Look After Them

In most organisations the administration/support team, although they can be... Read More

3 Steps To Successfully Build A Team In Any Program

Any x by y matrix plan has one big risk...... Read More

Boost Your Success With An R&D Team

One of the best ways to ensure that your planning... Read More

Building High Performing Teams: Putting the I Back in Teamwork

Ever watched a really brilliant idea meet with resistance and... Read More

Safety First - Five Reasons to Hold a Routine Safety Meeting

Workplace safety is important to all businesses for ethical, legal... Read More

Always In Motion Is The Future

It's the summer of 1973, and a young film director... Read More

Putting Your Expert Team Together

As a freelance writer myself, I know how important it... Read More

Teamwork in the Workplace: A Definition

A tight knit team is a group of competent individuals... Read More

Proactive High Performance Teamwork

Proactive High Performance Teamwork is made up of nine proactive... Read More

You are Excused from Training

Trainers, please picture this... You are presenting in a new... Read More

Motivating Your Employees

CREATE A MOTIVATIONAL CLIMATE: Create a climate where others find... Read More

Whats Your REAL problem??

When was the last time you spent excessive time and... Read More

Team Building Celebration Plan -- Perfect For Any Time of Year

When was your last team celebration? Have you been way... Read More

Intercultural Team Building

Internal business structures have been radically transformed over the past... Read More

Teams

For companies to be competitive, decisions have to be made... Read More

Collaboration Software - Building an Office Without Walls

The rise of the internet has given businesses a new... Read More

Communication between franchisees in a franchise system

If you own a franchise you would be wise to... Read More

Marche, or How Teams Work.

On the trail in Northern Canada "Marche" was the word... Read More

Team Development and Learning

A tight knit team is a group of competent individuals... Read More

Trust: A Critical Factor to Your Teams Success

True or false? Teams that practice good teamwork contribute to... Read More

elite cleaning services Buffalo Grove ...