Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) are growing. Investors are choosing low annual expense and market return over high annual expense and promised performance.
Total ETF inflow is growing faster than Mutual Fund inflow. ETF inflow grew from $42.5 billion in 2000 to $54.4 billion in 2004. In contrast, mutual fund inflow fell from $309.4 billion in 2000 to $180.3 billion in 2004. Standard & Poors Depositary Receipts Trust (SPY) is the largest and oldest ETF. From the one fund SPY started in 1993 the number of ETFs has grown to 150 in 2004.
Growth of ETFs is fueled by investors searching for market performance. About 20% of conventional mutual funds do beat the market. The puzzle is which funds will win, in the future. ETFs, on the other hand, have a reasonably good record of matching the performance of their underlying index. For instance, in 2004, SPY value grew 10.92% and the value of the underlying S&P 500 index grew at 10.88%. The promise of the conventional mutual fund is that it will deliver superior results. The promise of the ETF is that it will match the performance of its underlying index.
Expense for ETFs is less than for conventional mutual funds. A prime reason for the mutual funds' higher expense is that pros perceived capable of superior results are more expensive than technicians paid to duplicate the holdings of an index. ETFs are passive investments and don't require the active management of pros. Investors moving money from mutual funds to ETFs are trading promised performance and high expense for market returns and low annual expense. ETFs generally have expense ratios below 1. SPY's expense ratio is .12. Expense ratio is percent of assets consumed by fees annually.
Investors sticking with mutual funds have a couple of things going for them. Eliot Spitzer has used his New York State Office of Attorney General to scare/shame mutual funds into minding fiduciary duties to their investors. The growth of ETFs is pressuring mutual funds to reduce their expenses and to introduce ETFs mimicking mutual funds. Investors sticking with mutual funds might benefit from the growth of ETFs. However, mutual funds might have a hard time delivering. Slowing growth or actual decline in fund size will make it difficult to reduce their expenses enough to keep investors happy. The more investors defect the fewer left to share the expense.
ETFs trade like stock equities. They can be bought and sold whenever the market is open. They can be shorted, purchased on margin, and optioned. Most brokers charge a commission for every buy and sell transaction. This can be a problem for small investors building a portfolio with monthly contributions. There is at least one broker that charges an annual fee rather than per trade commissions.
ETFs are passive. They only trade when changes are made to the composition of the underlying index. Fewer trades mean less tax consequence. Mutual funds often have taxable capital gains, sometimes even in years when the fund has declined in value (sell winners and hold losers).
That 20% of mutual funds beat the market is a premise. It assumes multiply years and a market defined as the S&P 500. Meg Richards writing for The Associated Press reported that for 2004:
- The S&P500 bested 61.6% of actively managed large-cap funds.
- The S&P400 bested 61.8% of actively managed mid-cap funds.
- The S&P600 bested 85% of actively managed small-cap funds.
The probability of a mutual fund having beaten the market in 2004 is low. Of course, relative performance changes from year to year. Relative performance, of active versus passive management, changes. Relative performance, of individual actively managed funds, changes.
The best ETFs strategy for small, beginning, busy investors is to 'buy and hold' SPY. If you are bigger, experienced, or have time on your hands you can try a more active strategy. A strategy that beat the S&P500 over the last three years is to hold equal amounts of five large diversified ETFs and rebalance weekly. This strategy is in some ways just an expansion of our definition of 'the market' beyond the S&P500. This strategy since inception 3 years ago has beaten the S&P500 just over 1% annualized. This small gain means rebalancing weekly is only viable when it is without trading cost. A more aggressive strategy is to monitor 50 ETFs and hold the most oversold, rebalancing weekly. This strategy since inception 2/27/04 has beat the S&P500 by 16%.
Remember. ETFs' popularity is on the rise. They trade like stocks. They have lower annual expense than mutual funds. Their objective is to mimic the performance of an index. They don't beat or lose to the market, they are the market. It is usually best for low maintenance, 'buy and hold' investors to define the market as broadly as possible.
Lyle Wilkinson, investor, trader, author, MBA Helps individuals learn to self direct their stock portfolios. Book, e-book, PowerPoint "DIY Portfolio Management" http://www.diyportfoliomanagement.com http://www.diyportfoliomanagement.com
shuttle from Midway Glen Ellyn ..The higher the market goes the more confusing are the... Read More
An investor can find and research the best stock on... Read More
I often hear from people, "I don't trade. I invest.... Read More
Sometime in the third quarter of 1997, someone told me... Read More
Very few people, even professionals, have heard of the Dalbar... Read More
Ever wondered what is a mutual fund? A mutual fund... Read More
Disclaimer: Please note that I do not necessarily purchase, own,... Read More
Day trading is all about making buy and sell decisions.... Read More
Did you run out to buy that duct tape yet?... Read More
If you were to find that you had some severe... Read More
Ever done any whitewater rafting or canoeing? Long periods of... Read More
What does it take to be a stock trader? It... Read More
Success in small cap & micro cap stock trading like... Read More
It is finally catching up with them. The brokerage companies... Read More
We are already in it, but you can't see it.... Read More
Before we get into all the good news out there,... Read More
Robert Rodriguez likes to buy stocks at their lows. When... Read More
Mutual funds were moderately successful in creating a presence in... Read More
Wouldn't it be nice if you were only in the... Read More
Someday you may want to retire and continue to live... Read More
Did you know you can make money (and a lot... Read More
We learnt the following the hard way! If any of... Read More
How many times have you said to yourself, "I'd like... Read More
THERE'S SOMETHING TO BE SAID FOR standing firm in the... Read More
The broker told me not to sell because the mutual... Read More
shuttle from O'Hare North Chicago ..If you were to find that you had some severe... Read More
If you have talked to a stock broker or financial... Read More
AS BUILDERS BEGIN WORK ON THE FREEDOM TOWER in New... Read More
Time to look back2004 is over, now we are in... Read More
The Bollinger Band theory is designed to depict the volatility... Read More
There is so much involved in developing peak performance, that... Read More
A stock market index is a statistical measure of changes... Read More
The trading method you employ to approach the stock market... Read More
Mutual funds and brokers are always preaching not to buy... Read More
Minority Report the movie may not be far off if... Read More
Wall Street has been preaching the doctrine of Buy and... Read More
Mutual funds were moderately successful in creating a presence in... Read More
I don't know what kind it is, but I saw... Read More
Let's first define insanity. It is doing the same thing... Read More
In 1960 an engineer working for a watch company in... Read More
It is wonderful to be alive in the information age.... Read More
Intervention. Now don't let that big word scare you. The... Read More
Most people think the stock market is a zero sum... Read More
Four blind men were asked to give a description of... Read More
Cat or dog? Maybe Zebra. Shucks, I don't know, but... Read More
I receive emails from Morningstar. This company provides statistics and... Read More
On Monday, November 25, 2000 Investor's Business Daily listed on... Read More
You probably know the story of Sherlock Holmes and the... Read More
Let's go into the details of why non-indexed mutual funds... Read More
Every day in any financial publication you will find the... Read More
Stocks & Mutual Fund |